Hogan Lovells 2024 Election Impact and Congressional Outlook Report
15 November 2024
Recent regulatory developments of interest to all financial institutions. Among other things, includes many updates published for the end of the Brexit transition period. See also our sector specific updates in the Related Materials links.
After extensive negotiations, and within a week of the Brexit transition period ending on 31 December 2020, the UK and the EU finally announced on 24 December 2020 that they had agreed an EU-UK Trade and Cooperation Agreement (TCA). The UK ratified the TCA on 30 December and the TCA now applies provisionally until 28 February 2021, by which time it is hoped that the necessary EU ratification steps are completed, including the consent of the European Parliament and adoption by Council Decision. The TCA was brought into effect in UK law by the swift passing of the European Union (Future Relationship) Act 2020. The UK government has published a summary explainer.
In relation to financial services, the TCA confirms that UK and EU firms may benefit from third country access to each other's markets and non-discriminatory treatment. However, there are some carve-outs and "reservations". These include a typical "prudential carve-out" which allows both parties to take any measure it deems necessary for prudential reasons, such as protecting investors, depositors or policyholders, or ensuring the integrity and stability of their financial systems, so long as it is not used to avoid commitments under the TCA.
In addition, both the UK and the EU have exempted financial services from the most favoured nation (MFN) provision, which means that preferential terms granted to another party in the future need not be extended to the UK or the EU. They have also retained the right to impose a specific legal form on a financial services subsidiary (on a non-discriminatory basis).
The UK has some specific reservations in the TCA, for example, only firms having their registered office in the UK can act as depositaries of the assets of investment funds. This reservation also states that the establishment of a specialised management company, having its head office and registered office in the UK, is required to perform the management of common funds, including unit trusts, and where allowed under national law, investment companies.
The TCA includes provision confirming that it covers any new service that could be supplied under existing regulation. It also guarantees access by foreign firms to any self-regulatory bodies required for the conduct of their business, and to public clearing and payments systems.
In the TCA, the UK and EU also agree to make best endeavours to ensure that internationally agreed standards in the financial services sector for regulation and supervision, for the fight against money laundering and terrorist financing, and for the fight against tax evasion and avoidance, are implemented and applied in their territory. These include standards adopted by the G20, the FSB, the BCBS, the IAIS, IOSCO and the FATF.
Accompanying the TCA is a Joint Declaration on financial services regulatory cooperation in which the UK and the EU agree to enter into a memorandum of understanding by March 2021 establishing a framework for regulatory cooperation on financial services. This framework will be based on a shared commitment to preserve financial stability, market integrity, and the protection of investors and consumers. It will facilitate:
In addition, the UK and EU commit to "discuss" how to move forward with equivalence decisions.
The TCA does not include any provision for equivalence in financial services. In its Q&A on the TCA, the Commission explains that these are unilateral decisions for each party and are not subject to negotiation. The Commission notes that it has assessed the UK's replies to the Commission's equivalence questionnaires in 28 areas. However, the Commission requires further clarifications from the UK, particularly in relation to how the UK will diverge from EU frameworks, how it will use its supervisory discretion regarding EU firms, and how the UK's temporary regimes will affect EU firms. The Commission reiterates that it will consider granting equivalence when it is in the EU's interest.
Key dates to watch are the 28 February 2021 deadline for the end of the provisional application of the TCA and March 2021 for the deadline for the regulatory cooperation MoU.
If you would like to discuss the impact of the TCA on your business, please get in touch with your usual Hogan Lovells contact or a member of our Brexit Taskforce. For an overview of the impact of the TCA on data protection, read our separate briefing here.
HM Treasury has published a consultation and call for evidence on the UK regulatory approach to stablecoins and cryptoassets. The consultation paper represents the first stage in HM Treasury's consultative process on the broader regulatory approach to cryptoassets and stablecoins. It wants to ensure the UK regulatory framework is equipped to harness the benefits of new technologies, supporting innovation and competition, while mitigating risks to consumers and financial stability.
HM Treasury proposes an incremental, phased approach to regulatory adjustments, and a proportionate approach to regulation that is sensitive to risks posed and responsive to new market developments. The approach would be rooted in the principle of "same risk, same regulatory outcome". The objectives and principles would be set by the government and HM Treasury, with detailed rules set by the regulators. HM Treasury plans to maintain the current division of UK regulator responsibilities as far as possible.
The consultation paper focuses on establishing a sound regulatory environment for stablecoins, where HM Treasury judges that risks and opportunities are most urgent. If appropriate standards and regulation can be met, HM Treasury considers that certain stablecoins have the potential to play an important role in retail and cross-border payments, including in settlement. It proposes to introduce a regulatory regime for "stable tokens" used as a means of payment, covering firms issuing stable tokens and firms providing services relating to them, either directly or indirectly, to consumers.
The use of currently unregulated tokens and associated activities primarily for speculative investment purposes, such as Bitcoin, could initially remain outside the regulatory perimeter for conduct and prudential purposes. Utility tokens (those used to access a service) could also remain outside the perimeter. To a longer timetable, HM Treasury will consider the case for bringing a broader set of cryptoasset market actors or tokens within the scope of regulation.
The paper also includes a call for evidence on cryptoassets used for investment and the broader use of distributed ledger technology in financial markets.
The deadline for comments on the paper is 21 March 2021.
If the proposals are adopted, further consultations and guidance will be issued by HM Treasury and relevant regulators on implementation, including specific firm requirements.
Separately, the House of Commons European Scrutiny Committee considered, in section 4 of its 33rd report of the 2019-21 session, the EU's proposed Regulation on markets in cryptoassets (MiCA), proposed Regulation on a pilot regime for market infrastructures based on distributed ledger technology (DLT) and proposed Directive amending MiFID to clarify the legal position of certain cryptoassets under existing EU financial services legislation. The Committee explains that the new EU rules will not apply directly to or in the UK under the post-Brexit transition period. Nevertheless, it is concerned that the EU proposals raise several concerns which it discusses in its report.
The Committee will continue to scrutinise developments in the EU legislative process.
HM Treasury has published a response to its joint consultation paper with the Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS) on expanding the dormant assets scheme established under the Dormant Bank and Building Society Accounts Act 2008.
The UK dormant accounts scheme is currently narrower in scope than other international schemes, with only bank and building society accounts included. HM Treasury and DCMS consulted on expanding the scheme between February and July 2020.
Having considered all responses, which showed widespread support, the government intends to legislate to include additional assets from the insurance and pensions, investment and wealth management, and securities sectors in the scheme. Assets proposed to be within the scope of the expansion include:
Once the scheme is expanded, participants must continue to first make efforts, based on industry best practice, to reunite assets with their owners. Where that is not possible, more businesses will be allowed to participate in voluntarily transferring dormant assets into the scheme. People will still be able to reclaim their assets in full at any time.
Funding raised through expanding the scheme will enable continued support of good causes, social investments and environmental initiatives.
The government intends to legislate to expand the scheme when parliamentary time allows. It recognises and welcomes the strong interest in how future dormant assets funding could be spent and is considering whether this is an area that should be reviewed.
The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has published a new webpage on passporting in and out of Gibraltar and the Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA) has published a new webpage on Gibraltar passporting arrangements.
The PRA explains that the transitional arrangements preserving deemed passporting for Gibraltarian firms after the end of the transition period have been extended until 31 December 2021 and can be further extended until such time as the permanent arrangements of the Gibraltar Authorisation Regime are in place. The PRA provides an overview of outward passporting to Gibraltar and inward passporting from Gibraltar. It also covers how the PRA assesses outward passporting firms and changes to the original passport notification. Until further notice, the PRA requests that all passport notifications in accordance with the Capital Requirements Directive (CRD) and Solvency II Directive are submitted by email only, not sent by post.
The FCA webpage covers how to apply for, change or cancel a passport, the passporting fees payable and the time it takes for the FCA to process passport notifications. It also includes information on passporting rights for UK appointed representatives, UK tied agents in Gibraltar, and UK-authorised payment institutions and registered account information service providers with several agents.
The PRA has published a policy statement, PS30/20, on changes to its rules and onshored binding technical standards, as well as the use of temporary transitional directions, required before the end of the Brexit transition period. In particular, PS30/20 contains the final versions of the PRA Rulebook: (EU Exit) Instrument 2020 (PRA 2020/29) (set out in Appendix 1), the PRA transitional direction (set out in Appendix 2) and related guidance (set out in Appendices 4 to 7).
The PRA published these initially as near-final drafts as part of a joint Bank of England (BoE) and PRA policy statement, PS27/20, on 18 December 2020. However, following the making of the PRA's rules implementing CRD V, the PRA Rulebook: (EU Exit) Instrument 2020 and the PRA transitional direction have now been made and published as final versions, together with related guidance. The PRA has not made any changes to these materials from the near-final versions previously published.
Most provisions of the Instrument commenced at 11pm on 31 December 2020 (IP completion day). However, a small number of provisions will take effect at different times. The transitional direction came into force on IP completion day. In general terms, it delays onshoring changes that fall within the PRA's remit. It will apply until 31 March 2022, unless otherwise stated in the direction or if it is varied or revoked before then.
The FCA has published a webpage linking to memoranda of understanding (MoUs) it has entered into with European authorities in the areas of securities, insurance and pensions, and banking:
The FCA has published a press release about regulatory changes for firms as the Brexit transition period ends. The press release refers to several changes to existing systems and services, including:
To prepare for the end of the transition period, the FCA made further EU exit-related changes to its Handbook and Binding Technical Standards for which, in some cases, it shares responsibility with the PRA or the BofE. These changes ensure that a functioning regulatory and legal framework for financial services continues to be in place after the transition period.
The updates follow the publication in September of the FCA's CP20/18 containing draft onshoring-related instruments. The final instruments are largely unchanged from the versions consulted on in CP20/18, and these changes are outlined in the FCA's Handbook Notice 83.
The FCA's Temporary Transition Power (TTP) directions have also been made and published. The TTP applies transitional provisions to financial services legislation for a temporary period. The TTP will be applied on a broad basis from the end of the transition period until 31 March 2022, although there are some areas where the TTP will not apply which are detailed on an FCA webpage.
The FCA has published a series of new directions, notifications and forms, which it and firms will need to use now the Brexit transition period has ended.
Forms relating to benchmarks
Forms relating to credit rating agencies (CRAs)
Notification forms
Directions
The FCA and the BoE have published press releases highlighting the need for firms to complete the transition from sterling LIBOR by the end of 2021, alongside an updated version of the priorities and roadmap document produced by the Working Group on Sterling Risk-Free Reference Rates.
The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) has published an update on the progress of its ongoing investigation, launched in November 2018, into alleged anti-competitive arrangements in the financial services sector. The CMA confirms that, following the end of the UK-EU transition period, the CMA’s investigation will continue into suspected anti-competitive arrangements which may infringe the Chapter I prohibition of the Competition Act.
The CMA had stated that its initial investigation would continue until December 2020. It now states that the investigation will continue from January 2021 to September 2021, including further information gathering and analysis.
The PRA and FCA have jointly published an updated statement on the impact of COVID-19 on the Senior Managers and Certification Regime (SMCR), setting out their expectations of dual-regulated firms. The statement provides an update to the flexibility they previously offered in their April 2020 statement.
The regulators state that, as firms have adapted to the impact of the pandemic over the past months, their current expectation is that firms' application of the SMCR rules returns to normal. They have therefore ended the provisions that were previously available. Their explanation of what this means for firms includes:
The FCA has published an updated statement on the impact of COVID-19 on the SMCR, setting out its expectations of solo-regulated firms. The statement provides an update to the additional flexibility the FCA communicated in its April 2020 statement.
In this latest statement, the FCA also explains that, as firms have adapted to the impact of the pandemic over the past few months, it expects that firms' application of the SMCR rules will return to normal. Some of the previously available provisions ended on 7 January 2021 and the relevant modifications by consent will end after 30 April 2021. The FCA provides more detail below on what this means, which includes:
The FCA has made little change from its previous statement relating to furloughed staff.
The FCA has published an updated statement setting out its expectations to help firms using appointed representative arrangements apply the approved persons regime during the COVID-19 pandemic. The statement provides an update to its June 2020 statement.
The FCA explains that, as firms have adapted to the impact of the pandemic over the past few months, it expects that firms' application of the SMCR rules will return to normal. Some of the previously available provisions ended on 7 January 2021 and the relevant modifications by consent will end after 30 April 2021. The FCA provides more detail below on what this means, which includes:
On 8 January 2021, the FCA updated its webpage on firms' financial crime systems and controls during the COVID-19 pandemic which allowed some flexibility, on a risk-assessed basis, to firms' financial crime systems and controls. The FCA's update informs firms that its statement will expire on 7 February 2021.
On 7 January 2021, the FCA published a new webpage setting out the data it has obtained as a result of carrying out its COVID-19 financial resilience survey during 2020. It also announced, on 8 January 2021, that it will carry out a further survey of firms to help it understand the change in their financial resilience as a result of COVID-19. The FCA intends to email the survey to the relevant firms during the period of 13 January to 19 January 2021. Completion of the survey is mandatory.
On 18 December 2020, the European Systemic Risk Board (ESRB) published a press release summarising discussions at the 40th regular meeting of its General Board, which was held on 15 December 2020. Among other things, it decided to revise and extend its initial recommendation on restrictions of distributions during the COVID-19 pandemic by way of a further recommendation (dated 15 December 2020).
The revised Recommendation aims to ensure that firms maintain a sufficiently high level of capital to mitigate systemic risk and contribute to economic recovery in case of further economic disruptions. It recommends that relevant authorities ask banks, investment firms, insurers and reinsurers to refrain from distributions that have the effect of reducing the quantity or quality of own funds, unless firms apply extreme caution in carrying out distributions and the resulting reduction does not exceed the conservative threshold set by their competent authority.
Previously the General Board included central counterparties (CCPs) within the scope of its recommendation. However, ESMA's CCP stress test exercise confirmed the overall operational resilience of EU CCPs to common shocks and multiple defaults for credit, liquidity and concentration stress risks. Considering the effectiveness of the measures deployed by CCPs to mitigate operational risk, the General Board decided that it is no longer necessary to include CCPs within the scope of the recommendation.
The revised recommendation will apply until 30 September 2021. The ESRB will continue to monitor the recommendation's implications on firms and will decide if it needs to be further amended.
On 17 December 2020, the EBA published a letter (dated 9 December 2020) asking the European Commission to revise the deadlines for the submission of certain draft RTS and implementing technical standards (ITS) required under the Capital Requirements Regulation, the Capital Requirements Directive and the Investment Firms Regulation that were due to be delivered by the end of December 2020 or 1 January 2021.
The EBA requests new time limits for the submission of these RTS and ITS because of the lengthened consultation periods due to COVID-19 and needing to put on hold data collections normally used for ad-hoc impact or cost-benefit analyses.
The EBA is also requesting a delay to a report required under Article 44 of the Securitisation Regulation which it now expects to complete by the end of March 2021.
ESMA has published a final report containing guidelines on outsourcing to cloud service providers (CSPs). The guidelines aim to help firms and competent authorities identify, address and monitor the risks and challenges arising from cloud outsourcing arrangements, from making the decision to outsource, selecting a cloud service provider, monitoring outsourced activities to providing for exit strategies.
ESMA consulted on the guidelines in June 2020. In general, respondents agreed with ESMA's approach towards outsourcing to CSPs. The final report provides an overview of the feedback it received and explains how ESMA took this feedback into account.
The guidelines apply from 31 July 2021 to all cloud outsourcing arrangements entered, renewed or amended on or after that date. ESMA states that firms should review and amend accordingly existing cloud outsourcing arrangements with a view to ensuring that they take into account the guidelines by 31 December 2022. Where the review of cloud outsourcing arrangements of critical or important functions is not finalised by 31 December 2022, firms should inform their competent authority, including the measures they plan to take to complete the review or their possible exit strategy.
The guidelines will be translated into the official EU languages and published on ESMA's website. The publication of the translations in all official languages of the EU will trigger a two-month period during which competent authorities must notify ESMA whether they comply or intend to comply with the guidelines.
The European Commission has adopted a Delegated Regulation supplementing the Pan-European Personal Pension Product (PEPP) Regulation with regard to regulatory technical standards (RTS) specifying the requirements on information documents, on the costs and fees included in the cost cap, and on risk mitigation techniques for the PEPP.
The Council of the EU and the European Parliament will now consider the Delegated Regulation. If neither object, the Delegated Regulation will be published in the Official Journal of the EU (OJ) and enter into force on the twentieth day following its publication in the OJ.
The International Organization of Securities Commissions (IOSCO) has published a report to help regulators and retail investors address the risks associated with cryptoassets. As well as identifying the specific risks of cryptoassets to investors, the report describes methods that regulators can use to provide educational material to retail investors on the risks of investing in cryptoassets.
IOSCO recommends that members adopt the material and educational approaches in the report best suited to their respective jurisdictions. It acknowledges that not all the report's material or educational approaches may be appropriate for all member jurisdictions or consistent with all members' legal and regulatory frameworks.
Authored by Yvonne Clapham